Electric fleets face a charging expenses blind spot
A survey of 250 fleet leaders finds many firms rely on drivers' own reports of home charging costs, raising expenses fraud concerns.
Fleet operators that run electric vehicles face a growing risk of expenses fraud tied to charging, according to Autocar. The outlet reports on a survey of 250 leaders in fleet, finance and procurement roles, commissioned by mobility software company Cubic3.
The findings point to a heavy reliance on trust. According to Autocar, 44 percent of electric vehicle fleets depend on drivers to report how much they spend on charging at home. Managers who use those self-reported figures may have limited independent visibility into what the business is actually paying for energy.
Verification problems appear widespread among the respondents. Autocar reports that 48 percent had expense claims they could not verify within the previous 12 months. Over the same period, 31 percent flagged unauthorised transactions on company credit, fuel or charging cards, and 30 percent had at least one suspected or confirmed case of fraud.
Autocar frames the numbers as a warning about oversight gaps rather than as evidence of wrongdoing by any particular group of drivers. The emphasis falls on systems that make claims hard to check, not on individual conduct.
Questions about how the figures were gathered, and what firms are doing in response, remain open.
Background
Company cars have long been a major route into vehicle ownership for businesses and their employees. Many fleets hand drivers a fuel card or a reimbursement policy to cover energy costs, and finance teams check those claims against receipts, mileage logs or card statements. Electric vehicles change that process. Public chargers usually produce a receipt or a billing record, but a home charger draws power from a household supply that is rarely metered for a single vehicle. To estimate the cost, a company typically has to rely on the driver's reported kilowatt-hours, a tariff rate, or an estimate based on mileage and vehicle efficiency.
Several approaches exist to narrow that gap. Some businesses reimburse at a fixed rate per mile or per month, which removes the need to measure energy use but can overpay or underpay depending on the actual consumption. Others install submetered home chargers, use telematics that record charging sessions, or require drivers to submit data from their vehicle or charging app. Each method involves a trade-off between accuracy, cost and privacy. Software platforms that handle fleet expenses and charging data have grown alongside electric fleets to address these issues.
Fraud risk is not unique to electric vehicles. Fuel cards have long been targeted by misuse, and expense claims in any business can be padded or duplicated. What changes with electric fleets is the number of claims that cannot be easily confirmed from a single third-party record, and the speed at which small, repeated irregularities can accumulate across a large fleet.
Why it matters
Electric vehicles now account for a growing share of new company cars in many markets, so the way businesses track their energy costs has a direct effect on the economics of the switch. If a company cannot accurately measure what its vehicles cost to run, it cannot judge whether electrification is saving money, and it cannot set reliable budgets. Unverifiable claims also erode the trust that makes an expense policy work, both for finance teams and for the many drivers who submit honest claims.
The figures reported by Autocar suggest that many organisations are still working with approximate data. In some tax systems, accurate records of business and private use of a company vehicle can also matter for compliance. Gaps in documentation could create problems during an audit even where no fraud has occurred.
There is also a broader question about total cost of ownership. Electric cars are often promoted on running costs, and those savings depend on how and where the energy is bought. If fleet managers are working from estimates, the savings they report may not match reality. Better metering would give a clearer picture for procurement decisions, vehicle selection and future charging infrastructure.
What to watch
The first thing to watch is whether fleets respond by changing how they handle home charging, for example through submetering, standard reimbursement rates or direct integration with charging data. Any shift toward automatic records would reduce reliance on self-reporting.
Second, watch whether finance and audit bodies issue guidance on verifying home charging claims. Clear rules would give firms a common baseline and make it easier to compare practices.
Third, look for follow-up research. A repeat survey or independent study would show whether the verification gap is narrowing or growing as more electric vehicles join company fleets.
Finally, keep an eye on the software and service providers that sell fleet expense and charging tools. Their adoption rates and product changes may signal how seriously businesses are treating the issue.
Viewpoints
Commentary from our columns: three angles on this story.
The Accountant price, value and running costs
Every business that runs electric cars has a simple question to answer: what does one mile actually cost? For many fleets, the honest answer is still a guess. When 44 percent of electric vehicle fleets depend on drivers to report what they spend charging at home, the running-cost figures on a spreadsheet are only as reliable as those reports. That is a problem for budgets, for lease decisions and for any claim that switching to electric has cut costs.
The fix does not need to be dramatic. A fixed monthly allowance based on expected mileage can remove the temptation to over-claim, though it may overpay some drivers and underpay others. Submetered chargers or charging-app exports cost money up front but turn a vague estimate into a record. Even a simple monthly reconciliation of claims against tariff rates would catch the outliers.
Finance teams should treat home charging like any other cash expense: documented, sampled and reviewed. Electric cars can still be excellent value. The numbers simply need to be checked before anyone celebrates them.
The Skeptic open questions and weak points
The headline numbers are striking, and they deserve some caution. A survey of 250 leaders, commissioned by a company that sells mobility software, tells us what those respondents experienced and how they feel about their own controls. It does not tell us how common fraud is across all fleets, or how much money is lost. Those are different questions, and the difference matters.
The more useful point is structural. A claim that cannot be verified is not the same as a claim that is false. Many of these gaps may come from weak processes rather than deliberate misconduct. Still, a process that depends on memory, estimates and self-declaration will produce disputes, and some of those disputes will be hard to resolve.
Before accepting any conclusion, readers should ask how the survey was conducted, how fraud was defined and whether the figures reflect a growing problem or simply better detection. Those answers would make the warning far more persuasive.
The Commuter the everyday buyer's view
If you drive a company electric car, the home charging question is more personal than it sounds. Plugging in at night is the easiest part of owning one. The harder part is the paperwork. Many of us have been told to keep a rough note of what we pay, or to estimate it, and most of us are doing our best to be fair about it. That is exactly why a clear system matters.
A good setup would be simple from the driver's side. A charger that records energy use, a standard reimbursement rate that everyone can see, or an app that exports sessions without extra steps would all cut the guesswork. Nobody wants to spend evenings reconstructing kilowatt-hours from a utility bill.
The report is a reminder that trust works better when the process is transparent. Clear rules protect the honest drivers as much as the company, and they make the switch to electric feel less like a bureaucratic chore.